Which would be a better choice in the long run?

Okay so it's summertime and to make a long story short. I'm not allowed to date until I'm 18 and even then I can only date someone of my religion. Yet I keep having bf's! And so by the end of this summer my mom said that I have to decide if I want to be homeschooled to "avoid temptation". However on the last day of school I met this great guy who is looking for a serious relationship and doesn't mind that I want to stay a virgin until marriage. What should I do? Stay at school and maybe get with the love of my life yet have my mom Mad at me or be good yet have regrets?